1. Jewish immigration to Palestine v Palestine Arab population (graph)




























    Jewish immigration to Palestine v Palestine Arab population (table)





























    Various names for Palestine (1800s-present)

    1. Independent Sanjak of Jerusalem, Sanjak of: Nablus and Acre (Ottoman Palestine /‘Southern Syria’/Bilad el-Sham) (-1918)
    2. Occupied Enemy Territory (1918-1920)
    3. British controlled Palestine as a result of the San Remo Conference (April 1920-1922)
    4. British Mandate Palestine as a result of the League of Nations (1922-15 May 1948)
    5. Israel (1948-)
    6. West Bank (Jordanian occupied 1948-1967)
    7. Gaza (Egyptian occupied 1948-1967)
    6. West Bank (Israeli occupied 1967-) (Area A, B, C - Oslo Accords, 1993)
    7. Gaza (Israeli occupied 1967-)


    (Compiled by Stewart Mills, 15/7/13)

     Palestine and the administrative regions of the Ottoman empire
    The Ottoman Empire was divided into vilayets, (provinces). These were also called beyliks [beylerbeyilik] eyalets or pashaluks. The governor of a vilâyet was called beylerbeyi or vadi. At the height of its empire there were 29 vilayets. One of those was Syria. Vilayet (1864-1918) The Vilayets were introduced with the promulgation of the "Vilayet Law" (Turkish: Teskil-i Vilayet Nizamnamesi)in 1864, as part of the administrative reforms that were being enacted throughout the empire.Unlike the previous eyalet system, the 1864 law established a hierarchy of administrative units: the vilayet, liva/sanjak, kaza and village council, to which the 1871 Vilayet Law added the nabiye. The 1864 law also specified the responsibilities of the governor (wali) of the vilayet and their councils. At the same time, the law left to the governors vast scope for independent action as well as responsibility, as part of a system intended to achieve a large degree of efficiency in ruling the provinces.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vassal_and_tributary_states_of_the_Ottoman_Empire http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Ottoman_Empire_territories 

    Currency of Palestine
    The money of Syria consists of piastres (Ar kirsh) at 40 paras (ar. fadda or masriyeh) each. English and French (and Russian) gold passes everywhere. Egyptian money is refused everywhere. http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-b-029-800.html 


    Extracts from the Peel Commission Report 1937

    The total area of Palestine
    The total area of Palestine is approximately 10,400 square miles or 27,009,000 dunums (Peel Commission Report p. 234.)

    The difference between Oriental Jews and Zionists
     “If the Jews had come to Palestine willing to fuse their life and culture with Arab life and culture, to accept the language of the majority, to contemplate the possibility of being some day ruled by that majority, then it is conceivable that they might have been as welcome and successful in Palestine as their ancestors in ‘Iraq or Egypt or Spain in the early days of the Diaspora. But it would have been wholly unreasonable to expect such an attitude on their part. It would have been the direct negation of Zionism, both on its social or political and on its cultural side.

    The Zionists came back to Palestine, on the one hand, to escape from an alien environment, to shake off the shadow of the ghetto, to free themselves from all the drawbacks of ” minority life “. On the other hand, they came back inspired with the faith that the Jewish genius, restored to its old home, could do things comparable with the things it had done in ancient days, Necessarily, therefore, the Hebrew language had to be the language of the National Home: necessarily Jewish nationalism was intensified by its foundation.

    Enlightened immigrants might take a highly sympathetic interest in Arab life and culture: but there could be no question of a Jewish fusion or ” assimilation ” with it, still less of a subordination.. The National Home could not be half-national. Nor, it need hardly be said, was the idea of the Arabs acquiescing on their side in a fusion of Arab with Jewish culture more imaginable, To quote the Arab delegates of 1922 again ‘Nature does not allow the creation of a spirit of co-operation between two peoples so different ’.* (Peel Commission p. 62)”

    Maps of Palestine in c.1898 

    Map of Jerusalem
    http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-c-084b-800.html 

    Jewish colonies Jerusalem 1:25,000 Jerusalem
    http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-c-084b-800.html 

    Jerusalem map
    http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-c-110b-
    http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-c-110b- 

    Jerusalem – immediate surrounding area – Kefr Silwan, Abu Dis http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-c-110b-2000.html 

    Jerusalem, Bet Jala, Bethlehem
    http://www.lib.utexas.edu/books/travel/593773/593773-c-110b-2000.html 

    Illegal immigration - What was the level of illegal immigration of Muslims, Christians and Jews to Palestine in the period 1920-1945? 

    The Peel Report whilst noting illegal immigration of Arabs from Palestine as occurring it does not priorities this as an issue of national significance. In contrast the issue of illegal immigration of Jews was made an issue of concern. Chapter X – Immigration pp 279- 2. Illegal Immigration pp. 289-292 

    Arab illegal immigration 
     “43…In a good year the amount of Illegal Immigration into Palestine [from Hauran] is negligible and confined to the younger members of large families whose presence is not required in the fields. Most persons in this category probably remain permanently in Palestine, wages there ‘being considerably higher than in Syria. According to an authoritative estimate as many as ten or eleven thousand Hauranis may go to Palestine temporarily in search of work in a really bad year. The Deputy Inspector-General of the Criminal Investigation Department has recently estimated that the number of Hauranis illegally in the country at the present time is roughly 2,500.”

     …45, The dimensions ‘of the volume, of illegal immigration from neighbouring territories are not known. There is evidence that many of these illegal immigrants have land in the neighbouring territories and leave their wives and families in those territories while seeking to augment their livelihood by labour in Palestine. There is evidence also that this form of illegal immigration is seasonal. It is probable that seasonal immigration leaves a residue in Palestine of people who have decided to settle permanently in the country. There is no evidence available to show that this residue is so considerable as seriously to disturb the general economy of Palestine.”

     Jewish illegal immigration 
     “33. Jewish illegal immigration has been going on side by side with authorized immigration … 

    34…The volume of illegal immigration appears to have reached its peak in 1933, and It was estimated that, in the two years 1932-3, the number of anauthorized settlers had risen to 22,400. Of this figure, 17,900 were travellers who remained in the country beyond tile authorized limit. 35. The third form 37 It man be mentioned that the ratio of recorded Jewish divorces to, recorded Jewish marriages is 40 per cent., and we are of opinion that a substantial part of this abnormal divorce rate is due to the marriages and divorces which enable foreign women to enter Palestine or remain in the country when, otherwise they would either be disqualified from entering or not qualified for admission as immigrants.” (Peel Commission p. 289-290).

    Arabs to take burden of Jews from Europe 
     “4. …Arabs throughout their history have not only been free from anti-Jewish sentiment but have also shown that the spirit ‘of compromise is, deeply rooted in their life. And he went on to express his sympathy with the fate of the Jews in Europe. ” There is no decent-minded person,” he said, ” who would not want to do everything humanly possible to relieve the distress‘ of those persons,” provided that it was “ not at the cost of inflicting a corresponding distress on another people.” Considering what the possibility of finding a refuge in Palestine. means to many thousands of suffering Jews, we cannot believe that the ” distress ” occasioned by Partition, great as it would be, is more than Arab generosity can bear. And in this, as in so much else connected with Palestine, it is not only the peoples of that country that have to be considered. The Jewish Problem is not the least of the many problems which are disturbing international relations at this critical time and obstructing the path to peace and prosperity. If the Arabs at some sacrifice could help to solve that problem, they would earn the gratitude not of the Jews alone but of all the Western World.”

    Transjordan 
    In the Peel Commission the question was raised about immigration of Jews to Trans-Jordan. However, this was essentially ruled out whilst ever there was conflict in Palestine. “2. The area of Trans-Jordan is about 34,000 square miles, and its present population is estimated at about 320,000. Thus while the country is almost two and a half times as big as Palestine it contains only about a quarter of its population, That population, moreover, includes a large number of Bedouin, whose pastoral life requires more land than would be needed if in course of time they were to settle down to agriculture. “7. …as long as Jews and Arabs quarrel in Palestine they are unlikely to agree elsewhere; and in Trans-Jordan as in other independent Arab States the door will only be opened to Jewish enterprise in so far as friendlier relations are established in Palestine.”

     Zionism the Jewish Agency and Jewish colonization in Palestine
     “72. The expenditure of the Jewish Agency for colonizing and other activities in Palestine is covered by the proceeds of the Palestine Foundation Fund, the control of which was in 1929 transferred by the Zionist Organisation to the enlarged Jewish Agency. The annual expenditure from that Fund in 1935-6 was ;₤330,000. The total expenditure for 1921-36 was ₤ 6,215,000 including ₤1,900,000 for agricultural colonisation, ₤478,000 for urban colonization, ₤487,000 for education, ₤817,000 for immigration and ₤523,000 for public works, etc. 73, The Jewish Agency occupies an imposing building in Jerusalem. Is divided into a variety ,of Departments such as the Political, Colonization, Immigration, Education, Treasury, Economic and Trade and Industry Departments, as well as a Department for the Settlement of German Jews. … 76. The principal aim of the Jewish Agency has been and is to secure the admission into Palestine of as many Jews as the country can absorb from an economic point of view. Realizing that the settlement of Jews on the land is a comparatively slow and limited process, the Zionist leaders embarked on a policy of industrial and town development, which seemed to offer possibilities for the absorption of large numbers of Jews. (Peel Commission p. 173) 

    Population of Palestine Population during the Ottoman times 
    Primary sources for understanding Palestine: Baedeker’s Palestine and Syria 3rd ed 1898

     K Baedeker (ed), Palestine and Syria” Handbook for Travellers 3rd edition, Leipsic, Karl Baedeker publisher, 1898

     The writer of the book is Dr Albert Socin Professor of Oriental Languages at Leipsic with the assistance of Dr Immanuel Benzinger




    Newt Gingrich’s  ‘invented’ people – images of Palestine prior to British occupation














    https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2147rank.html
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_territories
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Bank
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golan_Heights
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Plan_for_Palestine
    http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/partition_plan.html
    http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/mandate2.html
    http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/partition_plan.html


    http://www.metric-conversions.org/area/square-miles-to-square-kilometers.htm

    http://www.kylesconverter.com/area/dunams-to-square-kilometres

    http://uk.icahd.org/articles.asp?menu=6&submenu=2&site=J&article=38







  2. (Updated 14 December 2010)

    Whilst in Israel in 2000 I remember speaking with a settler. She said that in 1910 there were only 10,000 Arabs in Israel. I thought this sounded ridiculous, so when I returned to England I went to the British Library to research this question. A quick inspection of Encyclopaedia Britanica 1910 and Baedeker’s Travel Guide to Syria and Palestine 1876 proved the settler’s assertion was ludicrous. The following indicates my research on the population of Palestine from 1851-1995. It is important to remember that the region now called Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories has been known by a variety of names. In this blog the name ‘Greater Israel/’Greater Palestine’ refers to the following regions:

    1. Independent Sanjak of Jerusalem, Sanjak of: Nablus and Acre (Ottoman ‘Palestine’/‘Southern Syria’/Bilad el-Sham) (-1918)
    2. Occupied Enemy Territory (1918-1920)
    3. British controlled Palestine as a result of the San Remo Conference (April 1920-1922)
    4. British Mandate Palestine as a result of the League of Nations (1922-15 May 1948)
    5. Israel (16 May 1948 - ) + West Bank (Jordan), Gaza Strip (Egypt)
    6. Israel + Occupied Palestinian Territories (1967- )

    Ottoman Jerusalem (Jerusalemites)
    Vilayet (Wiki), Sanjak (Wiki);

    For a comprehensive account see:


    Year__Non-Jewish__Jewish___Percentage of __TOTAL
    ______Pop. (m*)_____Pop.____Non-Jewish/___POP
    ___________________________Jewish

    1851____327 000g____13 000g____96/4_______340 000
    1861____356 000g____13 000____96/4________369 000
    1881____442 000g____25 000d ___95/5________467 000
    1895____522 000g ____47 000a____92/8_______569 000
    1900____556 000g/c___50 000a/c__92/8______606 000
    1910____640 000g____60 000 ____91/9 ____700 000
    1914____675 000g ____85 000a____87/13____760 000
    1916____57 000a ____________________________
    1918____57 000a ----------------------------------------------
    1919____500 000d -----65 000d -------87/13------ 565 000
    1922____723 000g -------93 000g -----89/11 ------816 000
    1924____765 000g ------113 000g------87/13----- 878 000e
    1931____881 000g ------175 000a ------83/17---- 1 056 000
    1936___1 003 000g ------370 000d ----73/27---- 1 373 000
    1940___1 113 000g -------467 000a---- 70/30 ---1 580 000
    1945___1 295 000g -------564 000a---- 70/30--- 1 859 000
    1948___1 319 000b -------650 000f ----67/33---- 1 969 000

    1988 ---2 435 900h ------3 659 000h ---40/60--- 6 094 900
    1995L --3 247 000j -------4 607 800i ---41/59 ----7 854 800


    'The Population of Palestine Prior to 1948' (MidEast Web)

    References to Population Table

    a. Jewish figures: Statistical Abstract of Israel, no. 23 (1972), p.23—as cited in
    A.Shama & M. Iris, Immigration without Integration: 3rd World Jews in Israel, Massachusetts: Schenkman, 1977.
    b. non-Jewish/Palestinian Arab figures: J. Abu-Lughod, The Demographic Transformation of Palestine—as cited in I. Abu-Lughod, The Transformation of Palestine, North Western University Press, 1971, p.139-163—as cited in A.Shama & M. Iris, Immigration without Integration: 3rd World Jews in Israel, Massachusetts: Schenkman, 1977.
    c. Encyclopaedia Britannica 11th Edition (1910-11). Cambridge University Press.
    d. Palestine: Royal Commission (1937).
    e. Report on the Tour of Investigation in Palestine in 1925. League of Nations. Health Organization, Malaria Commission.(1925). Geneva.
    f. The Jewish Agency, Immigration Information Departments, 16 years of immigration to Israel (1964). Jerusalem—as cited in A.Shama & M. Iris, Immigration without Integration: 3rd World Jews in Israel, Massachusetts: Schenkman, 1977.
    g. McCarthy, Justin, The Population of Palestine: Population Statistics of the late Ottoman Period and the Mandate, Columbia University Press, 1990.
    h. Israel Central Bureau of Statistics 1989 p. 78 and p. 701—as cited in UN Population and Demographics in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip until 1990 by W. Ennab UNCTAD (24 June 1994).
    i. The Mitchell Report. Report of the Sharm el-Sheik Fact-Finding Committee -
    May 2001, USA. [Accessed CAABU]
    L. (i) Population of the State of Israel at 1995 was 5 612 3009 (1 004 500 Palestinian-Israeli (18%) 4 607 800 Israeli Jews (82%) )
    (ii) Population of the Occupied Palestinian Territories at 1995 was 2 242 500 Palestinians (934 000 from Gaza Strip, and 1 308 500 from West Bank)
    m. Note, the Jewish Settler population doubled in West Bank during 1993 - 2001 to 200 000 (this excludes the East Jerusalem population, which stood at 170 000 in 2001k.
    n. Arthur Balfour in 1917, referred to the two communities as Jewish and Non-Jewish. Note the percentage of 'non-Jewish' persons two years after the Balfour Declaration i.e. almost 9 persons out of ever 10 were 'non Jewish'.

    Links to further information on the population of Israel and Palestine

    Stewart Mills, Finding a common narrative of Palestine and Israel, 12 December 2010

    http://israelandpalestinediary.blogspot.com/2010/12/finding-common-narrative-for-palestine.html


    The Palestine Question: A Brief History Prepared for, and under the guidance of the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People, 1 July 1980

    http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/38D6C47FC5FB0CDD852575D6006C70D4

    The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem: 1917-1988 Part I, 1917-1947

    http://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/0/AEAC80E740C782E4852561150071FDB0

    Encyclopaedia Britannica 11th Edition (1910-11). Cambridge University Press, p 604

    http://www.archive.org/stream/encyclopdiabri20chis#page/604/mode/2up/search/palestine [original]

    http://www.1911encyclopedia.org/Palestine [html]

    [Population 650,000, two thirds Moslems, rest Christians and Jews.]

    Historic Images of Palestine and Israel


    Other sites
    Population in Urban Localities and Other Geographical Divisions. Provisional Data as of December 31, 2004. Central Bureau of Statistics. Jerusalem, April 2005

    CIA Factbook

    Historical Maps of the Middle East (The University of Texas, Libraries)

    "Palestine and Syria" 3rd Edition.
    Baedeker (1912).

    Often different writers who wish to push the notion that Palestine was a land with no people use Mark Twains description of Palestine to indicate the land was vacant. It would be interesting to see how Twain would respond to his reference being miscontrued today. Karl Baedeker's travel guides to Syria (Palestine) are another useful source to give an impression of the population demographics of the region.

    The following has been put together thanks to the work of the University of Texas Libraries which uploaded Baedeker's 3rd edition (1912) to Syria on their website.

    Population Syria (includes Southern Syria i.e Palestine)

    "The populaton of the sanjak of Jerusalem about 320,000 and that of the sanjak of Zor at 100,000. The total population of Syria is therefore not more than 3 or 3 and a quarter millions...which gives about the same density of population as in the State of Mississippi." (Baedeker Population 1xxix)

    Demographic breakdown - Vilayet Beirut, Suriya, Lebanon, Aleppo

    INDEX (p. 448)
    Map Syria and Palestine 1:3,000,000


    IX. Works on Palestine and Syria (p. cxvi)

    Jerusalem and its environs

    Description of Jaffa (p. 6)

    Map of Jaffa

    Population of Jaffa

    An account of the 'German Temple' sect of Christians who sought to establish a Christian colony in the 'Land of Promise'

    Ramleh (p.12)

    Map of Jerusalem

    Population of Jerusalem
    "According to a recent estimate the population numbers about 60,000, of whom about 7,000 are Muslims, 41,000 Jews and 12,800 Christians...The number of Jews has greatly risen of late years" (p. 33)

    The Haram esh Sherif (p. 36)

    The Mosque El-Aksa (p. 47)

    Wailing Place of the Jews (p. 56)

    Jaffa Suburb, Jerusalem (p. 81)

    Jerusalem map 1:25,000

    The Lepers' Hospital (p. 102)

    II. Judaea index

    Map of Jerusalem, Hebron, Jericho and the Dead Sea 1:250,000

    Bethlehem map 1:16,250

    Bet Jala (p. 128)

    Hebron (p. 135)

    Hebron Map 1:15,000

    Southern Palestine Map: Hebron, Gaza, Akaba 1:500,000

    Gaza (p. 142)

    Jericho (p. 151)

    The Dead Sea (p. 157)

    Amman map 1:22,500 (p. 171)

    Hauran (p. 180)

    Beersheba (p. 199)

    Masada (p. 201)

    Petra (p. 205)

    Sinai Peninsula Map 1:1,500,000

    Haifa Map 1:18,300

    Mt Carmel

    Haifa (p. 265)

    Acre Map (p. 269)

    Nazareth (p. 279)

    Kfar Birim (p. 295) [Father Elias Chacour's home town]

    Beiruit (p. 321)
    [120,000 of this 36,000 Muslims, 81,500 Christians, 2,500 Jews]

    Palmyra (p. 397)

    Antioch (p. 445)

    INDEX (p. 448)

    Map Syria and Palestine 1:3,000,000

    Population Syria (includes Southern Syria i.e Palestine)
    The populaton of the sanjak of Jerusalem about 320,000 and that of the sanjak of Zor at 100,000. The total population of Syria is therefore not more than 3 or 3 and a quarter millions...which gives about the same density of population as in the State of Mississippi." (Baedeker Population 1xxix)


    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    Letters

    The following is a letter I wrote to the World Net Daily in response to an article I saw on their website.

    23 December 2006.

    Dear Sir/Madam,

    I was deeply disturbed to read Joseph Farah's article in World Net Daily "The Jews took no one's land" (April 23, 2002). As an Australian we were fed the same rubbish by the English that the land was terra nullius, that it was a land without people ["civilised people"], therefore they could claim the land.

    Farah's use of the Baedeker's travel journal is one sided he does not cite the population of other regional centres in Palestine at the time like, Hebron (19,000 including 1500 Jews), Jaffa (35,000 of these 23,000 Mohammedeans, 5000 Christians, 7000 Jews), Gaza, (35,000 including 100 Jews) Acre (11,000 including 8000 Muslims), Nazareth (10,000 including 6,500 Christians and 3,500 Muslims) and Haifa (12,000 half of who are Muslim, the other half Christian as well as 1,600 Jews).

    According to noted Ottoman scholar Justin McCarthy by 1910, 91 percent of the population of Palestine [then part of Syria] was not Jewish and only 9 percent were Jewish (i.e 640,000 non-Jews to 60,000 Jews).

    This is why so many Palestinians are angry that the British planned to make the region a national home for the Jewish community given the obvious historical demographic differences.

    Could you please make a note of this error.

    Regards,

    Stewart Mills
Loading